Martin McDonagh has a particular style, one that I appreciated, but hadn’t fallen in love with. I figured Wild Horse Nine would be along the same lines; I’d respect it more than I loved it, especially after what felt like months of the trailer playing before every film I saw. But it was a red herring, because Wild Horse Nine was nothing like what the trailer teased in the best way possible. I came in expecting a CIA mission, but instead I received a meditation about life and how to exit it, and it was all for the better. It also asks: How far can you go to be loyal without abandoning all that you value?

Wild Horse Nine follows two CIA agents who have been stationed in Santiago, Chile in 1973 on a vacation to Easter Island before the coup they have planned commences. John Malkovich stars as Chris, the older CIA agent who has been doing nefarious deeds across the world for years. As Chris is writing/recording his memoirs, he’s reflecting on his time with the CIA, and he seems to have become disillusioned with the agency and concerned if he actually did bad things for good reasons. His CIA supervisors are upset about his desire to write and want it shut down. Sam Rockwell plays Lee, the younger agent who supports Chris in his older age and covers for him with their boss MJ, portrayed by Steve Buscemi. Along the way, they cross paths with two leftist Chilean girls, Monica (Mariana di Girolamo) and Alicia (Ailin Salas), who are also on vacation, and they end up connecting over the holiday.

John Malkovich is the star of the show. Positive reactions to his performance have been spreading like wildfire over the past couple months, and I’m in total agreement. Malkovich is both tender and prickly, equally hilarious as he is devastating. Chris is hardheaded and rash, and Malkovich gets to mumble through dialogue in a charming way. The character could be received with frustration if Malkovich didn’t play him so earnestly. Chris, at minimum, is morally ambiguous, but it never feels like the film is trying to excuse his actions and sanctify him.

Sam Rockwell, who won an Oscar for his previous collaboration with McDonagh, Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri, jumps back into it with ease. Rockwell is a fantastic comedic actor, but Lee is a more challenging role than one would expect. Rockwell must balance being exasperated, protective, defiant, loving and more in one role, and he accomplishes it all beautifully. Parker Posey, an equally talented comedic presence, plays his wife Margie, and turns him into a cuckold. Lee is also given the gift of constantly eating enormous amounts of food. It’s an underrated talent to be able to eat food onscreen and make it look good. It reminds me of his role as George W. Bush in Vice. There’s a scene of him eating chicken wings. No matter what you think of the movie, Rockwell eats the hell out of those wings and looks natural doing it.

McDonagh is an incredibly competent director, but his writing is where he shines. The direction is often in service of the excellent performances, where the actors get to chew on the incredible dialogue he’s written. Although, I have to appreciate the POV flourishes he included of Lee recording Chris on his own video camera. But overall, the best aspects of the film are the screenplay and the performances.

I was surprised, initially, at the tone of the film. Based on the trailer (its proliferation really affected expectations), it seemed a lighter, satirical tone was to be used, but instead it was strangely somber, almost off-putting compared to my preconceived notion. Once settled, McDonagh began to cook. Every rant, sass, and joke painted a better picture of the characters’ personalities. I could watch their rat-a-tat all day long. Based on the time period, there is a world where these two characters end up in a super plotty movie, but instead they can breathe and exist with a character-informed plot that still has a nice share of action. While The Banshees of Inisherin is also about two men with an age difference on an island who drive each other crazy, I felt anxious as the story progressed. Wild Horse Nine is oddly comforting and hopeful, despite the stakes technically being higher. It’s funny and surprisingly sweet, and easily likable, which was a refreshing experience from McDonagh’s other works.

One of the most surprising aspects is how sparse the score is throughout the film. The album itself is a mere 23 minutes long. Carter Burwell is a brilliant composer, but only having the score sprinkled in was the right move. It allows for the audience to experience the situation more similarly to the characters. Also, the aesthetic of Wild Horse Nine was so groovy, and felt accurate without being stereotypical. Our two leads took to the style of the 70s perfectly.

Wild Horse Nine is impossible to hate. Enjoyment doesn’t always equal quality, but in this case it’s intertwined. Opinions can range from like to love, but its contemplative and sentimental nature made me adore it. As a person who thinks about what criteria determines what a good friend is, I was moved by its final stance. The ending caused tears to well in my eyes, and made me want to watch it all over again. Anyone who comes in with a predetermined idea of what the film will be should let it go and trust McDonagh to take you along for a wonderful ride.

Grade: A

Oscars Prospects:
Likely: Best Picture, Best Director, Best Actor (John Malkovich), Best Supporting Actor (Sam Rockwell), Best Original Screenplay, Best Casting, Best Editing
Should Be Considered: Best Picture, Best Director, Best Actor (John Malkovich), Best Supporting Actor (Sam Rockwell), Best Original Screenplay, Best Casting, Best Editing

Where to Watch: In Theaters

Eva Kirby
She/her @eva_kirby21
Lives in Florida. Loves sports, Diet Coke, and rewatching Fleabag.
Favorite Director: James Cameron
Sign: Pisces

Leave a Reply

Trending